When We First Met (2018) is a delightful romantic comedy with a clever fantasy twist that breathes fresh life into the genre. The film follows Noah (Adam Devine), who meets the perfect woman, Avery (Alexandra Daddario), at a Halloween party. Despite an instant connection, he ends up firmly in the friend zone. Three years later, as she prepares to marry another man, a heartbroken Noah discovers a magical photo booth that sends him back to that fateful night. He gets repeated chances to relive their first meeting, desperately trying different approaches to become the man of her dreams.

Adam Devine brings his signature comedic charm to the lead role, perfectly balancing humor with genuine pathos as his character learns valuable lessons about authenticity. Alexandra Daddario is radiant as Avery, creating a character who is both aspirational and relatable. The supporting cast, including Shelley Hennig and Andrew Bachelor, provide excellent comedic moments that enhance the film's playful tone.

Director Ari Sandel keeps the pacing brisk and the tone light, ensuring the time-loop premise remains engaging without becoming repetitive. The film explores familiar romantic comedy themes—destiny, self-improvement, and the fear of missed opportunities—but does so with enough wit and heart to feel fresh. The production design, particularly the Halloween party sequences, is vibrant and immersive.

Viewers should watch When We First Met for its clever premise, strong chemistry between the leads, and its ultimately sweet message about being true to oneself. It's the perfect choice for anyone seeking an uplifting, funny romance with a magical twist that asks: if you could relive your biggest 'what if,' would you?